| |
|
|
|
OPTIMAL
HEALTH INSTITUTE
SUPPLEMENT
COST COMPARISON1
DAILY
NUTRIENT VALUPACK
Multivitamin & Multimineral
|
Supplement |
OHI |
One A Day
50 Plus* |
One A Day
Maximum** |
Centrum Silver# |
Centrum Performance## |
GNC Ultra Mega= |
|
Vitamin A (as natural
betacarotene) |
10,000 IU |
5000 IU |
5000 IU |
3500 IU |
3500 IU |
10,000 IU |
|
Vitamin C |
500 mg |
120 mg |
60 mg |
60 mg |
120 mg |
200 mg |
|
Vitamin D |
600 IU |
400 IU |
400 IU |
400 IU |
400 IU |
400 IU |
|
Vitamin E (as d-alpha
tocopherol) |
400 IU |
60 IU |
30 IU |
45 IU |
60 IU |
100 IU |
|
Vitamin B1 (thiamine) |
25 mg |
4.5 mg |
1.5 mg |
1.5 mg |
4.5 mg |
75 mg |
|
Vitamin B2
(riboflavin) |
25 mg |
3.4 mg |
1.7 mg |
1.7 mg |
5.1 mg |
75 mg |
|
Vitamin B3 (niacin) |
25 mg |
20 mg |
20 mg |
20 mg |
40 mg |
75 mg |
|
Vitamin B6
(pyridoxine) |
50 mg |
6 mg |
2 mg |
3 mg |
6 mg |
75 mg |
|
Folic Acid |
0.8 mg |
0.4 mg |
0.4 mg |
0.4 mg |
0.4 mg |
0.4 mg |
|
Vitamin B12 (cobalamin) |
0.2 mg |
0.3 mg |
0.06 mg |
0.25 mg |
0.18 mg |
.75 mg |
|
Biotin |
0.3 mg |
0.3 mg |
0.3 mg |
0.3 mg |
0.4 mg |
0.75 mg |
|
Pantothenic Acid |
100 mg |
15 mg |
10 mg |
10 mg |
10 mg |
75 mg |
|
Calcium |
1056 mg |
120 mg |
162 mg |
200 mg |
100 mg |
100 mg |
|
Trimethyl glycine (Betaine) |
50 mg |
0 (add 4.87 for Source Naturals brand) |
0 (add 4.87 for Source Naturals brand) |
0 (add 4.87 for Source Naturals brand) |
0 (add 4.87 for Source Naturals brand) |
10 mg (add 4.87 for Source Naturals brand) |
|
Arginine HCL |
100 mg |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
L-glutamine |
100 mg |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
Taurine |
100 mg |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
|
Coenzyme Q-10 |
50 mg |
0 (add 18.47 for Twinlab, Inc. brand) |
0 (add 18.47 for Twinlab, Inc. brand) |
0 (add 18.47 for Twinlab, Inc. brand) |
0 (add 18.47 for Twinlab, Inc. brand) |
0 (add 18.47 for Twinlab, Inc. brand) |
|
Lutein |
6 mg |
0 (add 5.38 for Twinlab, Inc. brand) |
0 (add 5.38 for Twinlab, Inc. brand) |
0.25 mg (add 5.38 for Twinlab, Inc. brand) |
0 (add 5.38 for Twinlab, Inc. brand) |
0 (add 5.38 for Twinlab, Inc. brand) |
|
Magnesium |
800 mg |
100 mg |
100 mg |
100 mg |
40 mg |
0 |
|
Zinc |
15 mg |
22.5 mg |
15 mg |
15 mg |
15 mg |
15 mg |
|
Selenium |
0.2 mg |
0.1 mg |
0.2 mg |
0.2 mg |
0.07 mg |
0.1 mg |
|
Copper |
2.5 mg |
2 mg |
2 mg |
2 mg |
2 mg |
.25 mg |
|
Manganese |
5 mg |
4 mg |
3.5 mg |
2 mg |
4 mg |
.06 mg |
|
Chromium |
0.2 mg |
0.18 mg |
0.65 mg |
0.15 mg |
0.12 mg |
0.1 mg |
|
Molybdenum |
0.1 mg |
0.94 mg |
0.16 mg |
0.75 mg |
0.75 mg |
0 |
|
Potassium |
100 mg (90 mg chloride) |
37.5 mg (34 mg chloride) |
80 mg (72 mg chloride) |
80 mg (72 mg chloride) |
80 mg (72 mg chloride) |
10 mg |
|
Boron |
3 mg |
0 |
0.15 mg |
0.15 mg |
0.6 mg |
1 mg |
Monthly
Cost
|
(included in total below) |
3.37 |
2.99 |
4.25 |
5.00 |
12.33 |
Additional Items Cost
|
N/A |
28.72 |
28.72 |
28.72 |
28.72 |
28.72 |
TOTAL COST MULTIVITAMIN and MULTIMINERAL
|
(included in total below) |
32.09 |
31.71 |
32.97 |
33.72 |
41.05 |
Antioxidant
|
Supplement |
OHI |
Bought Individually (30 day supply) |
Add Gary Nulls “Super Antioxidant” (30 day
supply) |
Bought Individually (30 day supply) |
Bought Individually |
GNC + other brands |
|
Grape Seed Extract 95% |
75 mg |
Nature’s Way, add 8.99 |
Nature’s Way, add 8.99 |
Nature’s Way, add 8.99 |
Nature’s Way, add 8.99 |
|
Green Tea Extract 90/50 |
200 mg |
Solaray, add 13.49 |
Solaray, add 13.49 |
Solaray, add 13.49 |
5 mg (add Solaray 13.49) |
|
Blueberry Leaf Extract |
200 mg |
Solaray, add 13.99 |
Solaray, add 13.99 |
Solaray, add 13.99 |
Solaray, add 13.99 |
|
Rosemary Extract |
150 mg |
Solaray, add 12.29 |
Solaray, add 12.29 |
Solaray, add 12.29 |
Solaray, add 12.29 |
|
Alpha Lipoic Acid |
100 mg |
TwinLab, add 10.97 |
TwinLab, add 10.97 |
TwinLab, add 10.97 |
1 mg (add GNC, 9.49) |
|
N- Acetylcysteine (NAC) |
200 mg |
Allergy Research, add 3.59 |
Allergy Research, add 3.59 |
Allergy Research, add 3.59 |
5 mg (add GNC NAC+ Glutathione, 9.49) |
|
Glutathione |
50 mg |
Solgar, add 6.12 |
Solgar, add 6.12 |
Solgar, add 6.12 |
|
Quercetin |
100 mg |
Allergy Research add 4.27 |
Allergy Research add 4.27 |
Allergy Research add 4.27 |
Allergy Research add 4.27 |
|
Silymarin extract 80% |
250 mg |
Country Life, add 9.60 |
Country Life, add 9.60 |
Country Life, add 9.60 |
Country Life, add 9.60 |
Additional Antioxidant Cost (30 day supply):
|
83.31 |
59.95 |
83.31 |
83.31 |
81.61 |
TOTAL COST MULTIVITAMIN, MULTIMINERAL AND ANTIOXIDANT
|
115.40 |
91.66 |
116.28 |
117.03 |
122.66 |
Omega 3 EFAs
|
Supplement |
OHI |
TwinLab
30 day supply of 1680 mg/day |
ZonePerfect
30 day supply of 2136 mg/day |
Carlson Laboratories
30 day supply of 2000 mg/day |
Solgar
34 day supply of 2100 mg/day |
GNC
25 day supply of 2100 mg/day |
|
Vitamin E |
20 IU |
|
Marine Lipid Oil
Concentrate
EPA
DHA |
4000 mg
1200 mg
800 mg |
Additional Omega 3 EFA Cost (equivalent amounts):
|
27.95 |
39.90 |
27.75 |
33.95 |
22.99 |
|
TOTAL COST (for 30 day
supply): |
92.50 |
143.35 |
131.56 |
144.03 |
150.98 |
145.65 |
*Also contains: 0.2 mg Vitamin K and 0.15 mg
iodine ** Also contains: 18 mg iron, 109 mg phosphorus, 0.15 mg iodine, 0.05 mg
nickel, 0.1 mg tin, 2 mg silicon, 0.1 mg vanadium
#Also contains: 0.1 mg Vitamin K, 48 mg
phosphorus, 0.15 mg iodine, 0.05 mg nickel, 2 mg silicon, 0.1 mg vanadium, 0.3
mg lycopene
##Also contains: 0.25 mg Vitamin K, 18 mg
iron, 48 mg phosphorus, 0.15 mg iodine, 50 mg Panax ginseng, 60 mg Ginkgo Biloba,
0.5 mg nickel, 4 mg silicon, 0.1 mg tin, 0.1 mg vanadium
=Also
contains: 18 mg iron, 0.15 mg iodine, 0.1 mg silica, 35 mg choline, 0.75 mg
inositol, 75 mg PABA, 25 mg rutin powder, 25 mg citrus bioflavonoids complex, 5
mg hesperidin complex
MEN’S
FORMULA
|
Supplement |
OHI
|
Roex Advanced Men’s Formula
(contains proprietary blend of vitamins B-6, D, E; copper; zinc; saw palmetto;
juniper; gutamic acid; glycine; lysine; soy; Echinacea; pygeum; pumpkin; and
cranberry) |
Nature’s Sunshine*
29.62 |
Nature’s Life Men’s 800 + Prostate Support**
24.95 |
Various Brands |
Various Brands |
|
Zinc |
15 mg |
15 mg |
15 mg |
Solgar 22 mg = 2.83 |
Gary Nulls 25 mg = 2.95 |
|
Saw Palmetto PE 25% |
1280 mg |
570 mg |
160 mg |
Solgar 1300 mg = 29.35 |
Source Naturals 1280 mg = 39.97 |
|
Nettle Root Extract |
50 mg |
30 mg |
150 mg |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
|
Pumpkin Seeds Extract |
50 mg |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
|
Alpha Lipoic Acid |
100 mg |
Add Twinlab 100 mg = 10.97 |
133 mg |
Natrol 100 mg = 9.99 |
Solgar 120 mg = 15.95 |
|
Quercetin |
100 mg |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
|
Coenzyme-Q-10 |
25 mg |
Vitamin Shoppe 30 mg = 14.31 |
TwinLab 30 mg = 12.66 |
Country Life 30 mg = 17.97 |
Vitamin Shoppe 30 mg = 14.31 |
|
Cost (for 30 day
supply) |
24.00 |
34.02 |
54.89 |
37.61 |
60.14 |
73.18 |
*Also contains: 162 mg pygeum, 105 mg
lycopene, 345 mg gotu kola **Also contains: 0.1 mg copper, 50 mg pygeum, 10 mg
beta sitosterol, 235 mg flax seed oil
WOMEN’S FORMULA
|
Supplement |
OHI |
MedQuest Post Menopausal Formula
(contains
black cohosh, dong quai, chastetree berry, green tea extract, red clover and
400 mg I-3-C) |
Total Health Women’s Formula* 25.00 |
Various Brands |
Various Brands |
Various Brands |
|
Calcium |
500 mg |
75 mg |
Vitamin Shoppe 600 mg = 11.47 |
TwinLab 500 mg = 3.83 |
Vitamin Shoppe Calcium Citrate 500 mg = 4.99 |
|
Alpha Lipoic Acid |
100 mg |
Add Twinlab 100 mg = 10.97 |
Add Twinlab 100 mg = 10.97 |
Natrol 100 mg = 9.99 |
Solgar 120 mg = 15.95 |
|
Quercetin |
100 mg |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
Couldn’t find amount individually |
|
Co-Q-10 |
25 mg |
Add Vitamin Shoppe 30 mg = 14.31 |
TwinLab 30 mg = 12.66 |
Country Life 30 mg = 17.97 |
Vitamin Shoppe 30 mg = 14.31 |
|
Indole-3-Carbinol
(I-3-C) |
200 mg |
Add America’s Finest 200 mg = 24.99 |
Solaray 200 mg = 60.98** |
Add America’s Finest 200 mg = 24.99 |
Solaray 200 mg = 60.98** |
|
Soy Extract 40%
Isoflavones |
200 mg |
15 mg |
Nature’s Way 200 mg = 19.99 |
TwinLab 200 mg = 42.37 |
Medquest 250 mg = 12.00 |
|
Tocotrienols 5% |
25 mg |
Add Vitamin Shoppe 35 mg = 13.97 |
Carlson Labs 36 mg = 16.63 |
TwinLab 25 mg = 9.98 |
Carlson Labs 36 mg = 16.63 |
|
Cost (for 30 day
supply) |
25.50 |
24.97 |
89.24 |
132.70 |
109.13 |
124.86 |
*Also contains: 55 mg phosphorus, .15 mg
iodine, 300 mg soy protein, 200 mg guggul, 200 mg ginseng, 150 tyrosine, 10 mg
bladderwrack **Also contains 50 mg cabbage, 50 mg kale, 120 mg vitamin C, 50 mg
broccoli, 50 mg brussel sprouts, 50 mg cauliflower
HEART FORMULA
|
Supplement |
OHI |
Life Plus Heart Formula |
Source Naturals Heart Science |
Allergy Research Group Coenzyme Q10 w/tocotrienols
– 35.70 |
Various Brands |
Various Brands |
|
Vitamin E (as d-alpha
tocopherol) |
200 IU |
21 IU |
Vitamin Shoppe 200 IU – 3.65 |
Country Life 200 IU = 5.64 |
|
Coenzyme Q-10 |
100 mg |
100 mg |
Nature’s Way 100 mg = 34.95 |
TwinLab 100 mg = 36.95 |
|
Carnitine |
200 mg |
Vitamin Shoppe 250 mg = 12.57 |
TwinLab 250 mg = 13.98 |
Source Naturals 250 mg = 7.37 |
|
Grape Seed Extract 95% |
100 mg |
Add TwinLab 100 mg = 18.95 |
Source Naturals 100 mg = 8.12 |
Vitamin Shoppe (standardized)100 mg = 14.97 |
|
Tocotrienols 5% |
50 mg |
25 mg |
TwinLab 50 mg = 19.97 |
TwinLab 50 mg = 19.97 |
|
Arginine HCl |
500 mg |
Add TwinLab 500 mg = 4.83 |
Allergy Research Group 500 mg = 4.35 |
Vitamin Shoppe 500 mg = 4.31 |
|
Taurine |
200 mg |
Add Country Life 200 mg = 17.10 |
Add Country Life 200 mg = 17.10 |
Add Country Life 200 mg = 17.10 |
|
Cost (for 30 day
supply) |
35.00 |
57.75 |
86.25 |
89.15 |
102.12 |
106.31 |
BRAIN FORMULA
|
Supplement |
OHI |
Focus Factor |
Life Plus Brain Formula |
Smart Nutrition “Get Smart” (+ Phosphatidyl
Serine) |
Various Brands |
Various Brands |
|
Phosphatidyl Serine |
200 mg |
|
|
ProHealth 200 mg = 49.95 |
Life Extension 200 mg = 32.37 |
|
Lecithin |
500 mg |
Solaray Lecithin 570 mg = 4.52 |
Pro Health 420 mg = 4.50 |
|
N Acetyl Carnitine HCL
(also known as Acetyl-L-Carnitine) |
600 mg |
TwinLab 500 mg = 31.95 |
GNC 500 mg = 29.99 |
|
Cost (for 30 day
supply) |
40.00 |
74.95 |
49.50 |
99.85 |
86.42 |
66.8 |
DIABETES FORMULA
|
Supplement |
OHI |
Solaray Glucoreg
|
Doctor’s Choice for Diabetics |
Pinnacle Insulene |
Dr. Wallach’s Ultimate “Duck Pack” Formula |
Various Brands |
|
Vitamin A (as natural
beta carotene) |
5000 IU |
Solgar 5000 IU = 2.31 |
|
Chromium |
400 mcg |
Chromax 400 mcg = 8.33 |
|
Alpha Lipoic Acid |
200 mg |
TwinLab 200 mg = 21.95 |
|
Lutein 5% |
3 mg |
Swanson Ultra 6 mg lutein
& 20 mg bilberry = 6.49 |
|
Bilberry 25% |
100 mg |
|
Centella Asiatica 10% (Gotu
Kola) |
100 mg |
Nature’s Answer 150 mg = 2.99 |
|
Butchers Broom Extract
10% |
200 mg |
Solgar 200 mg = 3.98 |
|
Vanadium |
0.1 mg |
Couldn’t find individually |
|
Vinpocetine |
5 mg |
Couldn’t find individually |
|
Cost (for 30 day
supply) |
22.00 |
34.98 |
39.47 |
28.15 |
175.50 |
46.05 |
JOINT FORMULA
|
Supplement |
OHI |
Nature’s Plus Ultimate Rx-Joint* |
Trace Minerals Research** |
Solaray Joint Gs Formula*** |
Twin Lab Joint Fuel+ |
Various Brands |
|
Vitamin C |
250 mg |
200 |
0 |
0 |
500 |
Twinlab 500 mg = 3.16 |
|
Glucosamine SO4 KCL |
1000 mg |
1000 |
1500 |
250 |
750 |
Enzymatic Therapy 1000 mg = 12.65 |
|
MSM |
500 mg |
1000 |
1000 |
0 |
0 |
Natrol 500 mg = 3.99 |
|
Chondroitin Sulfate 90
(BSE Certified) |
300 mg |
800 |
800 |
100 |
50 |
TwinLab 500 mg = 18.99 |
|
Centella Asiatica 10% (Gotu
Kola) |
100 mg |
0 |
0 |
25 |
0 |
Nature’s Answer 150 mg = 2.99 |
|
Bromelain 2400 |
100 mg |
0 |
0 |
100 |
100 |
Nature’s Plus 250 mg = 4.61 |
|
Tumeric Extract 95% |
250 mg |
0 |
0 |
0 |
350 |
Solaray 300 mg = 6.24 |
|
Cost (for 30 day
supply) |
18.00 |
36.37 |
34.93 |
25.99 |
38.96 |
52.63 |
*Also contains: 20 mg manganese **Also
contains: .37mg lithium, .25mg boron, 70 mg magnesium, 170 mg potassium, 380 mg
alfalfa leaf ***Also contains: 225 mg sea cucumber, 25 mg bilberry
+Also contains: 400 IU Vitamin E, 15 mg
zinc, .10 mg selenium
OMEGA 3 EFAs
|
Supplement |
OHI |
TwinLab
30 day supply of 1680 mg/day |
ZonePerfect
30 day supply of 2136 mg/day |
Carlson Laboratories
30 day supply of 2000 mg/day |
Solgar
34 day supply of 2100 mg/day |
GNC
25 day supply of 2100 mg/day |
|
Vitamin E |
20 IU |
|
Marine Lipid Oil
Concentrate
EPA
DHA |
4000 mg
1200 mg
800 mg
(2000 mg/day) |
Total Cost (for 30 day supply):
|
13.50
|
27.95 |
39.90 |
27.75 |
33.95 |
22.99 |
1
Cost comparison technique:
1.
Prices were obtained from either the October
2003 Vitamin Shoppe catalog or from a series of Internet searches (using
Google as the search engine). Internet searches were conducted in September
and October of 2003 using key words (e.g., “men’s formula, brain supplement,
joint formula, etc.). The Vitamin Shoppe’s extensive website was also used
to find comparable products. The product description (and pricing
information) of the products used in comparisons were printed and are on
file, as is the Vitamin Shoppe catalog.
2.
Every effort was made to find comparable
amounts of product ingredients. When that was not possible, amounts closest
to those in the OHI products were selected. Amounts (mg or IU) of
ingredients are noted in the tables.
3.
Unless otherwise noted, the prices listed are
for 30-day supplies. This was calculated by dividing the price by the
number of servings, then multiplying by 30. For example, a product priced
at 34.95 for a 50 day supply, would cost 20.97 for a 30 day supply (34.95
divided by 50 = 0.699 x 30 days = 20.97).
4.
Some products are labeled as containing a
“proprietary blend” of ingredients. This means that the ingredients are
listed, but without any amounts. This makes it impossible to tell whether
or not the product contains amounts which have been shown to have the
desired effect.
|
|
|
|
|
|